Studying the effect of source proximity in sperm whales and continous sonar in pilot whales using operational sonars - the 3S-2019-OPS cruise report
FFI-Report
2020
About the publication
Report number
20/01749
ISBN
978-82-464-3285-4
Format
PDF-document
Size
10.4 MB
Language
English
The 3S project is an international collaborative effort with the aim to investigate behavioral
reactions of cetaceans to naval sonar signals. The objectives of the third phase of the project
are to investigate if exposure to continuous active sonar (CAS) leads to different types or
severity of behavioral responses than exposure to traditional pulsed active sonar (PAS) signals,
and to investigate how the proximity of the source to a whale affects behavioral responses. This
report summarizes the efforts, activities and data collection of the 3S-2019-OPS research trial
conducted over 4 weeks in Norwegian waters in August-September 2019. The primary tasks of
the trial were to tag sperm whales with mixed-DTAGs and expose them to PAS at different
levels and ranges, and to tag long-finned pilot whales with Mixed-DTAG and expose them to
PAS and CAS.
When a target species was localized, a tag boat was launched and mixed-DTAGs
deployed. The mixed-DTAG contained a GPS, an Argos satellite transmitter, triaxial
accelerometers and magnetometer sensors, stereo acoustic sensors and a pressure sensor. In
addition to the tags, data on potential vocal responses or avoidance of the exposed area were
collected by two moored acoustic buoys. Tagged whales were subject to controlled sonar
exposure experiments (CEE). The experimental design involved dose escalation at different
ranges and maximum source levels using operational sources towed by the FFI research vessel
HU Sverdrup II (HUS) or the Norwegian Navy frigate KNM Otto Sverdrup (OSVE). The
experiments were conducted under permit from the Norwegian Animal Research Authority, and
all procedures were approved by the Animal Welfare Ethics Committee at the University of St
Andrews. A separate risk assessment and management plan was developed for the trial to
minimize risk to the environment and third parties.
During trial we deployed 24 tags onto 20 different animals (15 sperm whales and 5 pilot
whales), and collected 355 hours of tag data. We conducted 11 experiments, including 10
controlled exposure experiments with 25 exposure runs to sperm whales. Using the CAPTAS
source on OSVE we conducted 7 CEEs with 16 exposure runs, and using the SOCRATES
source on HUS we conducted 3 CEEs with 9 exposure runs. During 1 session with pilot whales
we only collected baseline data, because the tags detached prematurely before any exposures.
What we achieved during the trial was the collection of a unique dataset, and the trial is
considered to be successful. We expect that the data collected on sperm whales will be
sufficient to answer the questions related to the effect of source proximity on responses.
Unfortunately, the question of the effect of CAS on pilot whales cannot be answered with the
data collected. Additional field effort is required to achieve this. This primary task was given
significant priority, with 7-10 out of 24 days of ship time dedicated to it, and 20 hours of baseline
data collected on pilot whales. Despite this effort, the outcome was marginal. Weather
conditions were rough early in the trial when this task had highest priority, and no pilot/killer
whales were found in the protected fjords. When the weather was acceptable we found pilot
whales only once. Unfortunately, the behavior of the tagged pilot whales led to early tag release
in worsening weather, so no exposure experiment could be conducted.
A video showing the activities during the trial can be seen following this link.